ORAL AUDIT — gen_35_sodom_overthrow_cave
Live verifier run: 18 VERIFIED 0 FAILED 0 UNCHECKABLE — re-run:
python3 logic/solo_tools/verify_claims.py logic/oral_audit/manifests/gen_35_sodom_overthrow_cave_claims.jsonClaims manifest (verified live at render time)
| status | id | source | claim · evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| VERIFIED | G35-01 | Bavli Nazir 23a / Horayot 10b; Bereshit Rabbah 51 (via Minchat Shai on 19:33) | THE THIRD DOTTED PLACE: ובקומה ('and when she ROSE' — the elder daughter, 19:33) — the schools expound the dot: 'in her lying he knew not, but in her RISING he knew.' SNAPSHOT carries the dot in the stream (encoded at the qof-position where the tradition names the vav — attachment noted). Third of the ten reached, third present. he=ֽ/הּ |
| VERIFIED | G35-02 | Minchat Shai on Gen 19:33 (the Ramah: 'the first plene, the last defective') | ...and the dot has a SPELLING partner: the two risings of Lot's daughters — the FIRST (19:33) written PLENE with vav, the SECOND (19:35) DEFECTIVE (probed: no vav, no dot). The dotted vav exists only in the elder's rising — the letter the derash hangs on is the letter only that verse has. count=1 refs=['Gen 19:33'] |
| VERIFIED | G35-03 | Masekhet Soferim 4 (no dispute); Bavli Shevuot 35b; Rambam's codification (via Minchat Shai on 19:18) | THE ONE HOLY NAME OF LOT — the mirror of Abraham's one profane: 'all the Names said of Lot are PROFANE except this one, HOLY: אל נא אדני ... to KEEP MY SOUL ALIVE — He who has power to kill and to make alive' (19:18). SNAPSHOT: the nun in qamatz, the sacred-form pointing; the layer's fourth station, this time undisputed and codified. he=ָֽ/י |
| VERIFIED | G35-04 | Minchat Shai on Gen 19:16 (the Mikhlol; the Masorah's seven) | THE CHAIN OF HESITATION: ויתמהמה ('and he LINGERED') carries the SHALSHELET (the chain accent — Scripture's rarest, 'seven in the Masorah, quavering and pausing'), and its final mem takes QAMATZ because the chain has a pause's force. SNAPSHOT: the chain-sign in the stream — and the accent's whole-Torah census, probed direct, is EXACTLY FOUR: Lot's lingering (19:16), the servant's prayer (24:12), Joseph's refusal (39:8), the ordination slaughter (Lev 8:23); the Masorah's other three live in the Writings (edges). he=ָ֓הּ |
| VERIFIED | G35-05 | Minchat Shai on Gen 19:23 (the sevirin Masorah) | A SEVIRIN ('presumed') READING — a new Masorah class for the audit: השמש יצא ('the sun WENT OUT' — masculine verb on the usually-feminine sun): one of THREE places Scripture writes יצא where יצאה is presumed — one in the Torah (here), one in the Prophets, one in the Writings. SNAPSHOT: the masculine form stands. he=צָ֣א |
| VERIFIED | G35-06 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 19:23 | THE HE-TO-HE VERSE, opening: the sunrise verse BEGINS with he (השמש) — the Kitzur: the verse runs he-to-he, 'five mils he walked before the sun came out' (the letter-value of he = 5). initials=ה |
| VERIFIED | G35-07 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 19:23 | THE HE-TO-HE VERSE, closing: ...and ENDS with he (צערה, 'toward Zoar' — with the directional he). The five-mil escort reading rides the two letters (named). finals=ה |
| VERIFIED | G35-08 | Minchat Shai on Gen 19:25 and 19:8 (the Masorah of parashat Toledot) | THE EIGHT SHORT THESE: האל ('these' — the demonstrative written without its final he) — the Masorah: EIGHT in the language where האלה is presumed. SNAPSHOT, lemma-locked: exactly eight — TWO in this chapter (the daughters offered 'to THESE men,' 19:8; 'He overthrew THESE cities,' 19:25), Isaac's covenant pair (26:3/4), the abominations (Lev 18:27), and Deuteronomy's three. The overthrow rides a shortened word. count=8 refs=['Deut 19:11', 'Deut 4:42', 'Deut 7:22', 'Gen 19:25', 'Gen 19:8', 'Gen 26:3', 'Gen 26:4', 'Lev 18:27'] |
| VERIFIED | G35-09 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 19:14 | קומו צאו ('RISE, GO OUT of this place') — the pair exactly TWICE in the Torah: Lot's sons-in-law at midnight (19:14) and PHARAOH at midnight ('rise, go out from among my people,' Exod 12:31): Sodom's exit-formula is the Exodus' exit-formula — the Kitzur reads the mockers who stayed against those who died in the darkness (named). pairs=['Exod 12:31', 'Gen 19:14'] |
| VERIFIED | G35-10 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 19:31 | כדרך ('after the MANNER of...') — exactly TWICE in the Torah: 'the manner of all the earth' (the daughters' plan, 19:31) and 'a day's JOURNEY' of quail (Num 11:31) — the Kitzur: 'as here bed-manner, so there — they craved illicitly in asking the quail.' count=2 refs=['Gen 19:31', 'Num 11:31'] |
| VERIFIED | G35-11 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 19:32 | ונחיה ('that we may KEEP ALIVE seed') — the intensive-stem form exactly TWICE in the Torah, both in the cave (19:32, 19:34); the Masorah's third: 'that we may keep the HORSES AND MULES alive' (Ahab's famine, I Kings 18:5; edge) — 'they did a beast's deed' (Kitzur). Morph-locked census (the brothers' 'we shall live' rides the simple stem). count=2 refs=['Gen 19:32', 'Gen 19:34'] |
| VERIFIED | G35-12 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 19:34 | THE SLEEP IN THE FINALS: הצעירה הן שכבתי אמש ('...to the younger: behold, I lay last night') — the final letters, read backward, spell שינה ('SLEEP'): 'he was asleep and felt nothing' (the ordered string הניש verified; the reversal named). finals=הניש |
| VERIFIED | G35-13 | Minchat Shai on Gen 19:20 (the Masorah's mnemonic: 'Lot below, David above') | אמלטה נא ('let me ESCAPE, please') — read MIL'RA (stress forward) with DAGESH in the nun of the plea-word; its Scripture-twin (I Sam 20:29, David's escape-plea) reads mil'el — the Masorah's mnemonic: 'Lot below, David above.' SNAPSHOT: the doubled nun exact (the Samuel leg rides as an edge). he=ָּ֜א |
| VERIFIED | G35-14 | Minchat Shai on Gen 19:22 (the Ramah: 'none like it in the Torah') | עד באך ('until your COMING there') — defective (no vav) with the bare kaf: the Ramah marks it UNIQUE in the Torah, and Minchat Shai wonders aloud why the Masorah's Noach-list omits it. SNAPSHOT: one token, exactly as described. count=1 refs=['Gen 19:22'] |
| VERIFIED | G35-15 | Minchat Shai on Gen 19:30 (the Hilleli; the Ramah's three-plene rule) | THE ZOAR SPELLING LAW, full side: 'צוער three plene in this class' (the Ramah) — and the naming verse itself is the mnemonic ('therefore the city's name was called ZOAR,' 19:22). SNAPSHOT: plene at the naming. he=ֹעַר |
| VERIFIED | G35-16 | Minchat Shai on Gen 19:30 (the same rule's lean side) | THE ZOAR SPELLING LAW, lean side: the VERY NEXT VERSE writes the city defective (צערה, 'toward Zoar,' 19:23) — as do the war-annal's tokens (13:10, 14:2, 14:8) and Moses' vista (Deut 34:3): the city is full only at its naming and Lot's ascent (19:30's two, probed). One verse apart, the law turns. count=1 refs=['Gen 19:23'] |
| VERIFIED | G35-17 | Minchat Shai on Gen 19:28 (the Ramah) | כקיטר ('like the SMOKE of the kiln') — the Ramah: both smoke-words of the verse (the land's קיטר and the kiln's כקיטר) plene-yod, lean-vav. SNAPSHOT: both, in the one verse where Abraham looks down on the overthrow. count=1 refs=['Gen 19:28'] |
| VERIFIED | G35-18 | Minchat Shai on Gen 19:31 (our books and the Masorah — against the Hilleli) | לבוא ('to COME in to us') — the Hilleli copy reads defective; all our books and the Masorah's own nine-defective list (which omits this one) rule PLENE. SNAPSHOT: plene — the run's first arbitration AGAINST the Hilleli. he=֣וֹא |
FOLDED INTO THE UNIT same day (one source of truth). Block 9 of the fourth run. Zero web fetches. Manifest: logic/oral_audit/manifests/gen_35_sodom_overthrow_cave_claims.json — 18 VERIFIED · 0 FAILED · 0 UNCHECKABLE, zero-iteration pass.
Sources: Minchat Shai on Gen 19 (30 notes — the run's densest) · Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 19 (8 notes) · Bavli Nazir 23a / Horayot 10b · Masekhet Soferim 4 · span map (Bereshit Rabbah 50-51).
CROWNS (chain-attested + DB-verified)
- G35-01/02 the third dotted place — and its spelling partner: ובקומה ("and when she ROSE," the elder daughter, 19:33) — the schools' dot: "in her lying he knew not; in her RISING he knew." SNAPSHOT carries the dot in the stream (third of the ten reached, third present; encoded at the qof-position where the tradition names the vav — noted). AND the Ramah's spelling rule locks the derash to the letter: the FIRST rising plene with vav, the SECOND (19:35) defective — no vav, no dot (probed). The dotted vav exists only in the verse the exposition needs it in.
- G35-03 the one holy Name of Lot: the MIRROR of last block's find — "all the Names said of Lot are profane except this one, holy: 'my Lord... to keep my soul ALIVE — He who has power to kill and make alive'" (19:18; Soferim without dispute, Shevuot 35b, codified by Rambam). SNAPSHOT: nun in qamatz, the sacred-form pointing. Two chapters, two one-exceptions, in opposite directions.
- G35-04 the chain of hesitation: ויתמהמה ("and he LINGERED") under the SHALSHELET (the chain accent — Scripture's rarest), its final mem in qamatz by the chain's pause-force. SNAPSHOT: the chain-sign present — and the accent's whole-Torah census, probed direct, is EXACTLY FOUR: Lot's lingering, the servant's prayer (24:12), Joseph's refusal (39:8), the ordination slaughter (Lev 8:23); the Masorah's Scripture-seven adds the Writings' three (edges). A rare-accent census locked at the letter level.
- G35-05 a SEVIRIN reading — new Masorah class: השמש יצא ("the sun WENT OUT" — masculine verb on the usually-feminine sun): one of THREE places Scripture writes against the presumed form — one per division of the canon. SNAPSHOT: the masculine stands. The presumed-readings list joins the audit's class roster.
- G35-06/07 the he-to-he sunrise: the verse runs from השמש to צערה — he to he: "five mils he walked before sunrise" (the letter-value of he; Kitzur). Both boundary letters verified.
- G35-08 the eight short THESE: האל ("these" without its final he) — the Masorah's EIGHT where האלה is presumed; SNAPSHOT, lemma-locked: exactly eight, TWO in this chapter (the daughters offered "to THESE men," the overthrow of "THESE cities") — the chapter's two darkest demonstratives ride the shortened word.
- G35-09 the two midnight exits: קומו צאו ("RISE, GO OUT") — exactly twice in the Torah: Lot's sons-in-law (19:14) and PHARAOH's midnight expulsion (Exod 12:31). Sodom's exit-formula IS the Exodus' exit-formula — the strongest intra-Torah edge of the run.
- G35-10/11 the cave's pairs: כדרך ("after the manner of") — twice: the daughters' plan and the quail's day-journey (Num 11:31; "they craved illicitly"); ונחיה ("that we may KEEP ALIVE seed") — the intensive stem exactly twice, both in the cave; the Masorah's third is Ahab keeping the HORSES alive (I Kings 18:5; edge): "a beast's deed" (Kitzur). Morph-locked.
- G35-12 the sleep in the finals: הצעירה הן שכבתי אמש — the finals read backward spell שינה ("sleep"): "he was asleep and felt nothing."
- G35-13 Lot below, David above: אמלטה נא ("let me escape, please") — stress forward with dagesh in the plea-word's nun; its Scripture-twin (David's escape-plea, I Sam 20:29) reads stress-back — the Masorah's own mnemonic maps the two escapes (edge).
- G35-14 the unique coming: עד באך ("until your coming there") — defective with bare kaf, Ramah-marked UNIQUE in the Torah; Minchat Shai wonders why the Noach-list omits it. One token, exactly.
- G35-15/16 the Zoar law turns in one verse: the city is PLENE at its naming ("therefore its name was called ZOAR," 19:22 — the Ramah's own mnemonic) and at Lot's ascent (19:30's two, probed) — and DEFECTIVE at the very next verse (צערה, 19:23), as in the war-annal and Moses' vista. Full at the naming, lean everywhere else.
- G35-17/18 closing arbitrations: כקיטר — both smoke-words of Abraham's look-down verse plene-yod lean-vav per the Ramah; לבוא ("to come in to us") PLENE with all our books and the Masorah AGAINST the Hilleli's defective — the run's first arbitration against the Hilleli copy.
DISCREPANCIES
None filed as rows (the dot's attachment-position note rides G35-01).
INHERITANCE EDGES (attested in export_links; Torah side verified)
- Gen 19:14 ↔ Exod 12:31 (intra-Torah, claim-borne) — the midnight exit-formula shared by Sodom and Egypt (G35-09).
- Claim-borne: I Kings 18:5 (Ahab's horses, G35-11) · I Sam 20:29 (David's escape-plea, G35-13) · Num 11:31 (the quail, G35-10) · the shalshelet's three Writings-legs (G35-04).
INSTRUMENT GAPS
- The galgal (wheel-sign) named TWICE more by Minchat Shai — on the nun of הנה נא ("behold, please," 19:2) and the aleph of הוציאם ("bring them out," 19:5) — recurrences #5-6 of the variant class.
- The single zarqa (bent stroke) on טרם ("before," 19:4) and the Ben Asher/Ben Naftali soft-kaf split at כהוציאם ("as they brought them out," 19:17 — Ben Asher soft, Ben Naftali hard; the discussion of telisha (the detached accent) in its small form) — filed to the accent-variant family.
READINGS FILED (named-only, unclaimed)
"That day they appointed him CHIEF JUDGE" (ישב written lean at 19:1 — Bereshit Rabbah 50, via Minchat Shai — the same lean-sitting device as 18:1's) · מי לך פה ("whom have you here") = בועז by letter-value — Boaz hinted at the door (Kitzur 19:12, arithmetic) · אשתו ("his wife") = עירית — her name by letter-value (Kitzur 19:26) · the four presumed-ההוא ("that") of the sevirin class, at בלילה הוא ("that night," 19:33) · pointing minutiae without rows: the dagesh-after-open-vowel pair — ויאמרו לא ("and they said: no," 19:2) and קומו צאו ("rise, go out," 19:14) — the Daniel-list class; ברחוב ("in the square") with the resh in sheva alone; אל תביט ("do not look") with bet in hiriq; הפכי ("my overthrowing") with he in bare qamatz; לעשות ("to do") plene with the ayin in hataf patach; ממחרת ("on the morrow") with the second mem bare of the wheel-sign; הוא אבי מואב ("he is the father of Moab") under the lengthening stroke, not the broken accent; גש הלאה ("stand back") in the Mikhlol's wide-qamatz weight class; ויפצרו ("and they pressed") with soft bet under qadma; לשבר ("to break") with no maqqef; הנמצאת ("who are found") and קרתי ("my beam") defective with the Hilleli and the Ramah.
TIMING + PROCESS NOTES
BLOCK CYCLE — 6 minutes 1 second (15:15:33-15:21:34). The program's densest Minchat Shai chapter (30 notes) triaged to 18 rows without loss of class-coverage: a third dotted place WITH its spelling-partner law, a fourth holy/profane station (mirrored), a rare-accent whole-census, and TWO new-to-the-audit Masorah classes (sevirin; the short-THESE eight). The shalshelet census — four tokens, probed at the codepoint level against the tradition's seven-with-mnemonic — is the block's model row.