ORAL AUDIT — gen_14_adam_line_ledger
python3 logic/solo_tools/verify_claims.py logic/oral_audit/manifests/gen_14_adam_line_ledger_claims.jsonClaims manifest (verified live at render time)
| status | id | source | claim · evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| VERIFIED | G14-01 | Minchat Shai on Gen 5:3 (Masorah alphabet; Ramah) | כצלמו ("AS his image," the man-to-son likeness) — the Masorah's alphabet-count: the pair occurs once with bet and once with kaf, "the first בצלמו with bet, the latter כצלמו with kaf, and the mnemonic is בצלמנו כדמותנו ('in our image, as our likeness')" (Ramah). SNAPSHOT: כצלמו unique, here. count=1 refs=['Gen 5:3'] |
| VERIFIED | G14-02 | Minchat Shai on Gen 5:3 (Masorah alphabet; Ramah) | בצלמו ("IN His image," the God-to-man direction, 1:27) — the pair's bet member, likewise unique: the two prepositions split the two directions of likeness across the two creation notices. count=1 refs=['Gen 1:27'] |
| VERIFIED | G14-03 | Minchat Shai on Gen 5:25-26 (Ramah; Hilleli) | שמונים ("eighty") — the Ramah: "ONE alone in the Torah is written plene with vav" — Methuselah's SECOND eighty (5:26, after he begot Lamech), plene with vav and yod; every other Torah eighty (including Methuselah's first, one verse earlier) defective. Minchat Shai calls the six-plene Masorah note "two errors"; SNAPSHOT sides with the Ramah: nine eighty-tokens, exactly one plene, at 5:26. full=['Gen 5:26'] of 9 tokens |
| VERIFIED | G14-04 | Minchat Shai on Gen 5:29 (Ramah; Hilleli) | ממעשנו ("from our work") in Noah's naming-speech — written DEFECTIVE without yod (the Ramah; the Hilleli records a dispute, "our books" defective). SNAPSHOT letter-exact. letters=ממעשנו vs ממעשנו |
| VERIFIED | G14-05 | Minchat Shai on Gen 5:29 | ומעצבון ("and from the toil") — the tsadi carries a dagesh (doubling dot): the toil-word's third and last Torah token (after the woman's and the man's sentences, 3:16/3:17 — this unit's own census), pointed exactly as its siblings. he=֣וֹן |
| VERIFIED | G14-06 | Minchat Shai on Gen 5:24 | כי לקח ("for [God] took him" — Enoch's exit) — כי joined by maqqef (the joining hyphen), not accented: the taking-clause reads as one breath. SNAPSHOT's maqqef data agrees. maqqef_after=1 |
| VERIFIED | G14-07 | Minchat Shai on Gen 5:5 | אשר חי ("which he lived," Adam's total) — אשר "with maqqef (joining hyphen), not with mehuppach (the inverted-horn accent)": SNAPSHOT joins it. maqqef_after=1 |
| VERIFIED | G14-08 | Minchat Shai on Gen 5:5 | ויהיו ("and all the days of Adam WERE") — "in most books with two gerishin" (gershayim, the double-stroke accent): SNAPSHOT reads gershayim on the ledger's first total. mark=gershayim |
| VERIFIED | G14-09 | Minchat Shai on Gen 5:18 | שתים ("two," in Jared's 162) — darga (the stair-step conjunctive accent) on the tav: SNAPSHOT agrees. mark=darga |
| VERIFIED | G14-10 | Minchat Shai on Gen 5:26 | מתושלח אחרי ("Methuselah, after...") — אחרי with pashta (the forward-leaning pause accent): SNAPSHOT agrees. mark=pashta |
| UNCHECKABLE | G14-11 | Minchat Shai on Gen 5 (eight setuma notes) | THE LEDGER'S ROW-BREAKS: Minchat Shai marks each generation's opening a CLOSED section (setuma) — 5:6, 5:9, 5:15, 5:18, 5:21, 5:25, 5:28, 5:32 all "closed" per the precise books: the death-ledger's rows are paragraph-ruled. SNAPSHOT carries no paragraph (petucha/setuma) instrumentation — gap class of gen_12's G12-11. no petucha/setuma columns in SNAPSHOT; the eight-row paragraph structure is real Masorah data the instrument cannot see |
| UNCHECKABLE | G14-12 | Minchat Shai on Gen 5:7 (galgal class) | הולידו ("after he begot," Seth's row) — Minchat Shai reads galgal ("wheel," the day-old-moon accent) on the dalet; SNAPSHOT's chain reads munach (a plain conjunctive) — the galgal-vs-SNAPSHOT variant class again (gen_11's G11-16 on 3:14): recurrence #2, same manuscript family difference. galgal absent from SNAPSHOT's mark inventory at this token (munach); manuscript accent-variant class, banked with G11-16 |
FOLDED INTO THE UNIT same day (one source of truth). Block 3 of the five-block timed run. Zero web fetches. Manifest: logic/oral_audit/manifests/gen_14_adam_line_ledger_claims.json — 10 VERIFIED · 0 FAILED · 2 UNCHECKABLE — second consecutive zero-iteration verifier pass. New verifier check type: maqqef_after (the joining hyphen lives in its own DB column).
Sources: Minchat Shai on Gen 5 (20 notes — the ledger is Masorah-dense) · Rashi on Gen 5 (8 notes) · Kitzur Baal HaTurim: no Gen 5 notes in the mirror · span map (Bereshit Rabbah 24-26).
CROWNS (chain-attested + DB-verified)
- G14-01/02 the two likeness-prepositions: בצלמו ("IN His image," God-to-man, 1:27) and כצלמו ("AS his image," man-to-son, 5:3) — the Masorah's alphabet-count pair, one bet, one kaf, with its mnemonic "in our image, as our likeness." Each token unique in the Torah; the two directions of likeness split across the two creation notices. Sits directly beside the unit's own image/likeness swap analysis (step C).
- G14-03 the one full eighty: שמונים ("eighty") written plene with vav EXACTLY ONCE in the Torah — Methuselah's second eighty (5:26); his first, one verse earlier, and all seven other Torah eighties are defective. The Ramah's rule verified against all nine tokens; Minchat Shai calls the rival six-plene note "two errors" — SNAPSHOT sides with the Ramah.
- G14-04 ממעשנו ("from our work," Noah's naming-speech, 5:29) — defective without yod per the Ramah; letter-exact.
- G14-05 ומעצבון ("and from the toil," 5:29) — tsadi dagesh (doubling dot): the toil-word's third and LAST Torah token, pointed exactly as its two sentence-siblings (3:16/3:17) — the unit's own toil-trio census attested at the pointing level.
- G14-06/07 the maqqef pair: כי לקח ("for God took him," Enoch's exit, 5:24) and אשר חי ("which he lived," Adam's total, 5:5) — both joined by maqqef (the joining hyphen) per Minchat Shai; SNAPSHOT's maqqef column agrees on both. First use of the new check type.
- G14-08/09/10 accent confirmations: gershayim (double-stroke) on ויהיו opening the ledger's first death-total (5:5); darga (stair-step) on שתים in Jared's row (5:18); pashta on אחרי in Methuselah's row (5:26) — all as Minchat Shai rules, all on SNAPSHOT's own marks.
READINGS FILED (named-only, unclaimed)
בדמות אלהים ("in the likeness of God," 5:1) — the Name here is HOLY (sacred, not the profane judges-sense; Minchat Shai's one-word ruling קדש) · on the day he was created, he begot (Bereshit Rabbah 24:7 via Rashi 5:1) · Enoch righteous but easily turned — "God took him before his time" (Bereshit Rabbah 25:1 via Rashi 5:24; beside the unit's lakach-loop and singular-total observations) · Noah's comfort = the PLOW — he made the first tools, releasing the thorns-curse (Rashi 5:29, Tanchuma — the reading rides the unit's 5:29 curse-citation analysis) · Noah's late fatherhood as flood arithmetic; Shem listed first for righteousness, born circumcised (Bereshit Rabbah 26:2-3 via Rashi 5:32).
DISCREPANCIES
None.
INSTRUMENT GAPS
- G14-11 the ledger's row-breaks: EIGHT closed-section (setuma) notes — every generation's row opens a closed paragraph per the precise books (5:6, 9, 15, 18, 21, 25, 28, 32): real structural Masorah the SNAPSHOT cannot see (no paragraph columns; class of gen_12's G12-11).
- G14-12 galgal ("wheel" accent) on הולידו (5:7) vs SNAPSHOT's munach — the galgal variant class, recurrence #2 (banked with gen_11's G11-16).
TIMING + PROCESS NOTES
BLOCK CYCLE — 3 minutes 47 seconds (13:14:47-13:18:34). Second zero-iteration verifier pass. The 32-verse ledger cost no more than a 10-verse narrative block: Masorah density, not verse count, drives audit time. maqqef_after check type added (~7 lines) — maqqef claims recur in Minchat Shai and were previously invisible. The setuma-per-row structure is the chapter's biggest unencoded fact — if paragraph data is ever ingested, Gen 5 is the test corpus.