ORAL AUDIT — lev_19_holiness_duty_ledger
Live verifier run: 13 VERIFIED 0 FAILED 2 UNCHECKABLE — re-run:
python3 logic/solo_tools/verify_claims.py logic/oral_audit/manifests/lev_19_holiness_duty_ledger_claims.jsonClaims manifest (verified live at render time)
| status | id | source | claim · evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| VERIFIED | L19-01 | Minchat Shai on Lev 19:2 | daber ('speak'), opening the holiness charge: 'with TWO geresh strokes' (gershayim, the double back-slanted accent) — in-stream. he=ֵּ֞ר |
| VERIFIED | L19-02 | Minchat Shai on Lev 19:4 | ha-elilim ('the idols'): MS rules 'the he with GALGAL (the wheel-accent)'; SNAPSHOT writes the munach (the upright conjunctive stroke) — galgal-class station 6, the camps splitting exactly as at the anointed priest's im (Lev 4:3). he=ִ֔ים |
| VERIFIED | L19-03 | Minchat Shai + Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Lev 19:5 (Baal HaTurim; Chullin 31; Rambam) | tizbachuhu ('you shall slaughter it') written LEAN — no vav after the chet — the Baal HaTurim: 'that two should not slaughter one sacrifice.' MS notes the halakha runs the OTHER way (the sages of Chullin: two MAY slaughter one offering; Rambam so rules) — the lean skeleton carries the rejected opinion. Once in the Torah. count=1 refs=['Lev 19:5'] |
| VERIFIED | L19-04 | Minchat Shai on Lev 19:6 quoting the Ramah | The Ramah's left-over rule: 'every notar-word (left over) in the Torah is FULL with vav, except ONE lean — ve-hanotar of the Passover night, parashat ha-chodesh.' The single lean skeleton stands exactly at Exod 12:10, his own sign. count=1 refs=['Exod 12:10'] |
| VERIFIED | L19-05 | Minchat Shai on Lev 19:6 quoting the Ramah | The rule's full side: ve-hanotar with the vav stands six times — the peace-offering pair (7:16/17), the investiture (8:32), the poor leper's oil twice (14:18/29), and this verse's third-day remainder. count=6 refs=['Lev 14:18', 'Lev 14:29', 'Lev 19:6', 'Lev 7:16', 'Lev 7:17', 'Lev 8:32'] |
| VERIFIED | L19-06 | Minchat Shai on Lev 19:8 | ki ('for') in 'for he has profaned the LORD's holy thing': 'with MAQQEF (the joining stroke), not with tevir (the broken third-rank pause)' — SNAPSHOT joins MS's camp: the stroke is in-stream. maqqef_after=1 |
| VERIFIED | L19-07 | Minchat Shai on Lev 19:19 | et chukotai tishmoru ('MY STATUTES you shall keep'): 'so it is written — the mem with HOLAM (the o-dot), not with sheva' — the rare o-pointed keep-verb, in-stream. he=רוּ֒ |
| VERIFIED | L19-08 | Minchat Shai on Lev 19:20 | ve-hi ('and she') of the bondwoman case: 'written with VAV and pointed with chiriq (the i-dot)' — the written-vav/read-yod class, the she-word wearing the he-word's skeleton, in-stream. he=ִ֤וא |
| VERIFIED | L19-09 | Minchat Shai on Lev 19:20 | ve-hafdeh ('and she shall be redeemed'): 'the he with qamatz ALONE (no stress-stroke) and the dalet DAGESHED (the hardening dot)' — the dagesh checked, the bare qamatz asserted at build. he=ֵּה֙ |
| VERIFIED | L19-10 | Minchat Shai on Lev 19:25 (the Hilleli and Yerushalmi codices; the Meiri; the Ramah) | ha-chamishit ('the fifth [year]'): the Hilleli codex wrote it doubly FULL; the Yerushalmi codex and the Masorah rule full-first-yod-lean-second, 'and it is marked UNIQUE — nothing else written so' — the Meiri and all precise books concur, the shin soft (asserted). SNAPSHOT with the Masorah against the Hilleli: the unique form stands here alone. count=1 refs=['Lev 19:25'] |
| VERIFIED | L19-11 | Minchat Shai on Lev 19:25 quoting the Ramah | The Ramah's fifth-word ledger, other classes: 'chamishit doubly FULL — two, sign: the fifth to Pharaoh, and he shall add the fifth of the Sanctifier's redemption' — exactly the two doubly-full stations in the stream (Gen 47:24, Lev 27:15); the lean-first class (Lev 27:19) asserted at build. count=2 refs=['Gen 47:24', 'Lev 27:15'] |
| VERIFIED | L19-12 | Minchat Shai on Lev 19:25 | tevuato ('ITS produce' — the tree's): written with final VAV; 'chumashim that write it with he are in plain error' — the he-for-vav endings exist only twice in Scripture, both in the Prophets (Jer 2:3, Ezek 48:18, outside the instrument). The vav-form stands once in the Torah, here. count=1 refs=['Lev 19:25'] |
| VERIFIED | L19-13 | Minchat Shai on Lev 19:32 and 19:34 | The chapter's dagesh pair: me-Elohekha ('[fear] your God', 19:32) — 'the mem DAGESHED'; ha-ger ('the stranger', 19:34) — 'the gimel DAGESHED' (checked and asserted respectively) — both hardening dots in-stream. he=י/ךָ |
| UNCHECKABLE | L19-14 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Lev 19:9 | 'FOUR reaping-words in the verse' — to exclude the four lost harvests: robbers reaped it, ants nibbled it, wind broke it, cattle ate it. The verse carries exactly four reap-root tokens (asserted at build by root; no span-count check type yet). |
| UNCHECKABLE | L19-15 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Lev 19:2 | 'TEN times the-LORD-your-God in this portion' — the Kedoshim portion (Lev 19-20) carries EXACTLY TEN adjacent pairs of the Name and 'your God' (eight in ch. 19, two in ch. 20; asserted at build) — the holiness charge sealed by a minyan of Names, for 'a matter of holiness needs ten.' |
FOLDED INTO THE UNIT same day. Block 8 of the eighth run — RUN COMPLETE, and with it the RETRO PROGRAM: all 62 frozen units now carry the oral layer. Zero web fetches. Manifest: logic/oral_audit/manifests/lev_19_holiness_duty_ledger_claims.json — 13 VERIFIED · 0 FAILED · 2 UNCHECKABLE.
Sources: Minchat Shai on Lev 19:2/4/5/6/8/13/19/20/25/26/27/31/ 32/34/37 · Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Lev 19 (twenty-plus notes) (the Hilleli and Yerushalmi codices; the Ramah; the Meiri; Chullin 31; Rambam; the Masorah — the counting tradition).
CROWNS
- L19-01 the double-stroked speak: דבר ("speak") opening the holiness charge — "with two geresh strokes"; in-stream.
- L19-02 the wheel-or-stroke again: האלילים ("the idols", 19:4) — MS rules the he carries galgal (the wheel-accent); SNAPSHOT writes munach (the upright conjunctive stroke) — galgal-class station 6, splitting exactly as at Lev 4:3.
- L19-03 the lean slaughter-word: תזבחהו ("you shall slaughter it", 19:5) LEAN — the Baal HaTurim: "that two should not slaughter one sacrifice"; MS notes the halakha runs the OTHER way (Chullin's sages, Rambam) — the lean skeleton carries the rejected opinion. Once in the Torah.
- L19-04/05 the Ramah's left-over rule, EXACT: "every notar-word ('left over') in the Torah FULL except ONE lean — the Passover night's." The single lean stands at Exod 12:10, his sign; the full והנותר ("and that left over") stands six times ending here.
- L19-06 the joined ki: "with maqqef (the joining stroke), not tevir (the broken pause)" — SNAPSHOT joins MS's camp.
- L19-07 the o-pointed keep: תשמרו of "MY STATUTES you shall keep" (19:19) — mem with holam, not the silent half-vowel; in-stream.
- L19-08/09 the bondwoman verse's marks: והוא ("and she") written with vav, pointed chiriq (the she-word in the he-word's skeleton); והפדה ("she shall be redeemed") — he with qamatz (the long a) ALONE, dalet dagheshed.
- L19-10/11 the fifth-word ledger + a codex split: החמישת ("the fifth year", 19:25) — the HILLELI codex wrote it doubly full; the YerushalmI codex and the Masorah rule full-first-lean-second, marked UNIQUE. SNAPSHOT sides with the Masorah AGAINST the Hilleli (the codex that was gen_04's authority). The Ramah's doubly-full pair (the fifth to Pharaoh, the Sanctifier's added fifth) exact in the stream.
- L19-12 its produce, with vav: תבואתו (19:25) — "chumashim writing it with he are in plain error"; the he-for-vav endings live only in the Prophets (Jer 2:3, Ezek 48:18, named). Once in the Torah.
- L19-13 the dagesh pair: מאלהיך ("[fear] your God", 19:32) mem dagheshed; הגר ("the stranger", 19:34) gimel dagheshed.
- L19-14 the four lost harvests: "FOUR reaping-words in the verse" (19:9) — excluding what robbers reaped, ants nibbled, wind broke, cattle ate; exactly four reap-root tokens (asserted; no span-count check type).
- L19-15 the minyan of Names: "TEN times the-LORD-your-God in this portion" — the Kedoshim portion (Lev 19-20) carries exactly ten adjacent pairs (8 + 2, asserted): a matter of holiness needs ten.
DISCREPANCIES / GAPS
- L19-02: galgal camp-membership uninstrumented; SNAPSHOT joins the munach camp (class station 6).
- L19-10: Hilleli-vs-Masorah split — first station where SNAPSHOT rules AGAINST the Hilleli.
- MS's soft-letter negatives — the gimel of תגזל ("you shall not rob"), the tav of תקפו ("you shall not round"), the qof of תבקשו ("do not seek"), all ruled undagheshed — build-asserted only; a not-contains check type would green them.
READINGS FILED (named-only)
The Kitzur's juxtaposition chains across the ledger (gleanings → theft; theft → denial → false oath; withheld wages → cursing the deaf; love-your-neighbor → forbidden mixtures; the judge neither soft to one nor hard to the other); the letter-count teachings (the corner = one-sixtieth; the razor not scissors; קעקע = writing the impure name, Makkot 21); "who dwells in the Land dwells without sin" (19:22-23); rising before an ignorant elder; the field-measure pair with the Sabbath-limit's two thousand cubits (19:35).
TIMING + PROCESS NOTES
Lean-record mode. Local mirror only, zero fetches. 37-verse ledger span, MS pointing-dense — 15 rows, the run's largest manifest, still under the run-7 first-block ceiling.