ORAL AUDIT — gen_64_pharaoh_dreams_rise
Live verifier run: 13 VERIFIED 0 FAILED 0 UNCHECKABLE — re-run:
python3 logic/solo_tools/verify_claims.py logic/oral_audit/manifests/gen_64_pharaoh_dreams_rise_claims.jsonClaims manifest (verified live at render time)
| status | id | source | claim · evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| VERIFIED | G64-01 | Minchat Shai on Gen 41:50 (the chilufim; Rav Paalim; the Great Masorah's note) | u-le-yosef YULAD ('and to Joseph were BORN two sons'): MS found ALL his books with qamatz — and the printed variance-lists rule that reading BEN NAPHTALI's, with BEN ASHER reading patach (Rav Paalim: 'patach for Ben Asher, qamatz for Ben Naphtali'). SNAPSHOT writes the PATACH — the stream with BEN ASHER against Ben Naphtali and against every book MS saw: the corpus's SECOND Ben Asher/Ben Naphtali station (after yehi or, Gen 1:3) — and the stream sides with Ben Asher both times. he=ַּד֙ |
| VERIFIED | G64-02 | Minchat Shai on Gen 41:14 (the Ramah; the Meiri; the Zohar; against the printers) | va-yeritzuhu ('and they RUSHED him from the pit'): some prints wrote it doubly lean and the Great Masorah's note misled Minchat Kohen; every precise manuscript, the Meiri, and the Ramah rule FULL yod, LEAN vav — and the Zohar reads the lean vav itself: who ran him out? the Holy One — 'for none binds and none looses but He.' Once in the Torah. count=1 refs=['Gen 41:14'] |
| VERIFIED | G64-03 | Minchat Shai on Gen 41:2 quoting the Ramah | va-tirena ('and they GRAZED'): 'two, doubly full — yod before the nun and final he' — the dream's grazing and its retelling (41:2, 41:18), census exact. count=2 refs=['Gen 41:18', 'Gen 41:2'] |
| VERIFIED | G64-04 | Minchat Shai on Gen 41:7 quoting the Ramah | The swallow-verb FLIPS between dream and retelling: va-tivlana (41:7) written with final he and the bent nun; va-tivlan (41:24) without the he, the nun straightened — the Ramah rules both stations, each once in the stream (the second asserted). count=1 refs=['Gen 41:7'] |
| VERIFIED | G64-05 | Minchat Shai on Gen 41:7 quoting the Ramah | ve-ha-meleot ('the FULL ears'): lean yod, full vav — 'and every other fullness-word in the Torah is lean except this one'; the books that write 41:22's melet full are in error (the Ramah: 'the precise texts and the Masorah dispute them'). The one full token checked. count=1 refs=['Gen 41:7'] |
| VERIFIED | G64-06 | Minchat Shai on Gen 41:26 (the Hilleli and Yerushalmi codices; the Ramah) | sheva PAROT ha-tovot ('the seven GOOD COWS', the interpretation's first word-pair): the Hilleli codex lean, the Yerushalmi full — and here the stream sides WITH the Hilleli: parot lean, marked unique-and-lean by the Masorah and the Ramah. The lean skeleton collides across the Torah with the EUPHRATES (perat — 2:14, 15:18, Deut 1:7, 11:24) and with Joseph's own blessing, ben PORAT ×2 (49:22): the cows, the river, and the fruitful bough share one skeleton, seven tokens. count=7 refs=['Deut 11:24', 'Deut 1:7', 'Gen 15:18', 'Gen 2:14', 'Gen 41:26', 'Gen 49:22'] |
| VERIFIED | G64-07 | Minchat Shai on Gen 41:27 quoting the Ramah | ve-ha-raot ('the EVIL cows', the interpretation's second mention): 'every evil-plural in the Torah is FULL except TWO lean' — this token, and lo tihye achare rabim LE-RAOT ('you shall not follow the many to evil', Exod 23:2, named): the lean evils are Pharaoh's cows and the perverted court. count=1 refs=['Gen 41:27'] |
| VERIFIED | G64-08 | Minchat Shai on Gen 41:23 quoting the Ramah | achare-hen ('after THEM', feminine): the form's WHOLE Torah career is this chapter's five tokens (41:3, 6, 19, 27, 30) — and the Ramah's own exception stands at 41:23: the one achare-HEM with mem inside the same dream-cycle (asserted). A word whose entire life is one chapter, minus one letter-slip the Masorah itself flagged. count=5 refs=['Gen 41:19', 'Gen 41:27', 'Gen 41:3', 'Gen 41:30', 'Gen 41:6'] |
| VERIFIED | G64-09 | Minchat Shai on Gen 41:45 (the Ramah; the Meiri; Yerushalmi Megilla; tractate Soferim; the old chumash) | The naming verse writes TWO two-word names: tzafnat paneach — 'they are ONE name written and read as two words' (the Ramah), the old chumash adding they must share one line; and poti fera — two words with NO maqqef between them (the precise books, Yerushalmi Megilla, Soferim). SNAPSHOT carries each as two unjoined tokens (poti's no-maqqef checked; all four tokens asserted) — the instrumented mirror of Potiphar-the-one-word (G62-01). maqqef_after=0 |
| VERIFIED | G64-10 | Minchat Shai on Gen 41:45 and 41:54 (most Sephardic precise books) | Two more wheel-rulings: the ayin-syllable of far'o at the naming (41:45) and the he of ha-aratzot ('all the LANDS', 41:54) — most precise books rule GALGAL on both; SNAPSHOT writes the munach at each: galgal-class stations 8 and 9, the stream's munach-camp membership now nine stations wide (both checked via the stroke in-stream, joined to the class file). he=֔וֹת |
| VERIFIED | G64-11 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 41:50 (the Masorah) | u-le-yosef ('and to Joseph') — exactly TWICE in the Torah, both Torah-side: two sons born before the famine (41:50), and Moses' blessing 'and to Joseph he said: blessed of the LORD is his land' (Deut 33:13): the Kitzur — who joins the community in its trouble lives to see its comfort. count=2 refs=['Deut 33:13', 'Gen 41:50'] |
| VERIFIED | G64-12 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 41:5 (the Masorah) | be-qane echad ('on ONE STALK') — exactly THREE in the Torah: the good ears twice (41:5, 41:22) and the made MENORAH's cups (Exod 37:19): the Kitzur — plenty is light for the world; only the good ears grow on one stalk, and the lamp shares their phrase. pairs=['Exod 37:19', 'Gen 41:22', 'Gen 41:5'] |
| VERIFIED | G64-13 | Minchat Shai on Gen 41:7/9/13/33/43/48/52/57 (the chapter's file) | The chapter's pointing-and-accent file: ha-beriot ('the healthy ears') with the bet DAGESHED (checked); anyi ('my affliction') with the ayin in qamatz alone, chazaq's zayin in patach, the was/were pair (hayu 41:48 / haya 41:53 — one of the Masorah's three such pairs, the Ezekiel sign named; both asserted); and the named file: yere (41:33) end-stressed against the custom — the Masorah's 'none other so'; be-mirkevet (41:43) — 'the only chiriq of its word'; ka-asher unjoined with the shin stroked (41:13); the et of 41:9 in segol; Chizkuni's four resh-tzere hollow-cows note (41:19). he=֖וֹת |
IN-PIPELINE (forward era, block 5 of run FWD-1 — RUN COMPLETE). Zero web fetches. Manifest: logic/oral_audit/manifests/gen_64_pharaoh_dreams_rise_claims.json — 13 VERIFIED · 0 FAILED · 0 UNCHECKABLE.
Sources: Minchat Shai on Gen 41 (thirty-six notes — the run's densest file) · Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 41 (twelve notes) (the chilufim — the printed variance-lists; Rav Paalim; the Ramah; the Meiri; the Zohar; the Hilleli and Yerushalmi codices; Yerushalmi Megilla; tractate Soferim; Chizkuni; the Masorah — the counting tradition).
CROWNS
- G64-01 BEN ASHER'S PATACH (the run's marquee): יֻלַּד ("were born", 41:50) — MS found every book with qamatz; the variance-lists call that Ben Naphtali's reading, patach Ben Asher's. SNAPSHOT writes the PATACH: the corpus's second Ben Asher/Ben Naphtali station (after "let there be light"), the stream with Ben Asher both times — here against every book MS saw.
- G64-02 rushed by the Holy One: ויריצהו full-yod-lean-vav (the Zohar on the lean vav: none binds and looses but He).
- G64-03/04/05 the dream/retelling letter-set: the doubly-full grazing pair exact; the swallow-verb sheds its he and straightens its nun between dream and retelling; the Torah's one full fullness-word at 41:7.
- G64-06 the Hilleli's lean cows: פרת unique-and-lean, the stream WITH the Hilleli against the Yerushalmi codex — and the skeleton collides with the Euphrates (×4) and Joseph's own fruitful bough (49:22 ×2): seven tokens locked.
- G64-07 the two lean evils: Pharaoh's cows and "after the many to evil" (Exod 23:2).
- G64-08 the word that lives in one chapter: אחריהן — its whole Torah career is this chapter's five tokens; the one mem-form (41:23) is the Ramah's own exception.
- G64-09 the two-word names: צפנת פענח one-name-two-words (one line, per the old chumash); פוטי פרע ("Poti-fera") unjoined — both carried as two tokens: the mirror of Potiphar-one-word.
- G64-10 wheel-stations 8 and 9: the books' galgal at the naming's far'o and at "all the lands" — SNAPSHOT's munach (the upright conjunctive stroke) at both; the class stands at nine stations, all munach.
- G64-11 the Joseph pair: וליוסף exactly twice — the two sons, and Moses' blessing (Deut 33:13).
- G64-12 one stalk: בקנה אחד exactly three — the good ears twice and the made menorah (Exod 37:19).
- G64-13 the chapter's file: the healthy-ears bet dagesheed (checked); ten more pointing/accent rulings asserted or named.
DISCREPANCIES / GAPS
- One census dropped at probe: the Ramah's four doubly-lean good-words — his list's scope against the 41:35 station unresolved; not framed rather than misframed.
- G64-01 doubles as a books-vs-stream split: SNAPSHOT against every codex MS collated (with Ben Asher's camp per the variance-lists).
READINGS FILED (named-only)
Avrekh's two readings; the cupbearer's three belittlings; the ten-year letter-sums; the granary pair; the appoint/gather contrasts with Ahasuerus; the kiss-pair; the circumcision teaching on "you shall do"; the four cups; Egypt's seven nations in the seven cows.
TIMING + PROCESS NOTES
In-pipeline scan; lean-record; zero fetches. The span is the corpus's longest single-chapter unit (57 verses, 776 tokens); the machine board ends EMPTY — the forward era's first fully discharged demand-queue.