ORAL AUDIT — gen_62_potifar_house
Live verifier run: 11 VERIFIED 0 FAILED 1 UNCHECKABLE — re-run:
python3 logic/solo_tools/verify_claims.py logic/oral_audit/manifests/gen_62_potifar_house_claims.jsonClaims manifest (verified live at render time)
| status | id | source | claim · evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| VERIFIED | G62-01 | Minchat Shai on Gen 39:1 quoting the Ramah (the Masorah's two-word list) | Potiphar is ONE written word, full yod and full vav — the Ramah's proof by omission: the Masorah's list of names written TWO words and read one (Poti-fera, Malki-tzedek, Baal-chanan, Tzafnat-paneach) does not count Potiphar. Both Torah stations single-token (39:1 checked bare; 37:36 with its lamed asserted). count=1 refs=['Gen 39:1'] |
| VERIFIED | G62-02 | Minchat Shai + Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 39:20 (the Great Masorah's alphabet-list) | asure ha-melekh ('the king's prisoners'): written with VAV, read with YOD — 'the FIRST of the Great Masorah's alphabet of words written vav in the middle and read yod.' SNAPSHOT carries the two-token pair in-stream (bare written form checked, pointed read-form asserted beside it). The Kitzur counts the years in it: ten for the slander of ten brothers, two more for the two remember-me's. in-verse count=1 |
| VERIFIED | G62-03 | Minchat Shai on Gen 39:22 (the Ramah; the Meiri; the Hilleli; against the printer) | ha-asirim ('ALL the prisoners'): the printer muddled it into the vav-list and Minchat Kohen followed; MS rules with the Ramah, the Meiri, and the Hilleli's note — written with yod after the samekh, lean in the second yod, no written/read pair here, marked UNIQUE. SNAPSHOT writes exactly that, once in the Torah. count=1 refs=['Gen 39:22'] |
| VERIFIED | G62-04 | Minchat Shai on Gen 39:8 quoting Rabbeinu Bachya | va-yemaen ('and he REFUSED') carries the chain-accent (shalshelet) — Bachya's principle stated on this very word: 'from the accents of the Torah we understand what is not written, as from a man's gestures we know his heart' — the mark draws the refusal out to its utmost. One of the whole-Torah FOUR chain-accent stations (gen_35's census); in-stream. he=אֵ֓ן |
| VERIFIED | G62-05 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 39:4 | 'And all he had he gave into his hand' — the five words' FINAL letters spell leshono ('his TONGUE'): Gabriel came and taught him seventy tongues, and so he prospered. Ordered finals checked in-stream. finals=לשונו |
| VERIFIED | G62-06 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 39:20 (the Masorah) | asurim ('bound') — the Kitzur's three: two with Joseph and one 'the LORD releases the bound' (Ps 146:7, outside the instrument). The Torah census is exactly the Joseph pair: his own binding (39:20) and his fellow-prisoners' (40:5, next unit's span) — the Kitzur's dialogue rides it: she said 'I will bind you'; he answered 'the LORD releases the bound.' count=2 refs=['Gen 39:20', 'Gen 40:5'] |
| VERIFIED | G62-07 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 39:15 (the Masorah) | harimoti ('I RAISED') — exactly TWICE in the Torah, both Torah-side: Abram's raised hand (the oath refusing Sodom's spoil, 14:22) and the wife's raised voice (the false cry, 39:15): the same word lifts an oath and a lie. count=2 refs=['Gen 14:22', 'Gen 39:15'] |
| VERIFIED | G62-08 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 39:1 (the Masorah) | hurad ('Joseph was BROUGHT DOWN') — the Kitzur pairs it with 'brought down to Sheol' (Isaiah, outside the instrument): exile weighed as the grave. The skeleton's own Torah pair: here passive, and re-pointed imperative at 'take DOWN your ornaments' (Exod 33:5, after the calf) — two descents, the slave's and the nation's. count=2 refs=['Exod 33:5', 'Gen 39:1'] |
| VERIFIED | G62-09 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 39:1 (the Masorah) | horiduhu ('they brought HIM down' / 'bring HIM down') — exactly TWICE in the Torah: the Ishmaelites bringing Joseph down to Egypt (39:1), and Joseph's own 'bring him down to me' over Benjamin (44:21): because Judah caused the one descent, he must perform the other — the Kitzur's measure-for-measure, census exact. count=2 refs=['Gen 39:1', 'Gen 44:21'] |
| VERIFIED | G62-10 | Minchat Shai on Gen 39:9/17/18 | The chapter's pointing set: ka-harimi ('as I raised my voice') — 'the he with sheva-and-patach' (the compound half-vowel), CHECKED under the guttural; le-tzacheq ('to mock me', 39:17) with the chet in segol, and ha-ze ('this') with the zayin dagesheed (asserted). he=ִ֥/י |
| VERIFIED | G62-11 | Minchat Shai on Gen 39:23 | roe et-kal ('saw not ANY thing'): MS rules et 'with maqqef and WITHOUT a stress-stroke' in the precise books. SNAPSHOT joins the maqqef (checked) but WRITES the meteg MS's books omit (asserted at build) — a pointing DISCREPANCY, the stream against MS's camp, filed to the watchlist. maqqef_after=1 |
| UNCHECKABLE | G62-12 | Minchat Shai on Gen 39:7 (Rambam; the Hilleli; the Meiri; Et Sofer) | 'And it was after these things' (the wife's eyes lift): the Sephardic precise books write NO paragraph break here; Rambam's list and the Hilleli make it OPEN; the Meiri declines to rule and leaves a closed-parasha gap; Et Sofer holds no-break as the essence. Paragraph layer uninstrumented — filed with the camps recorded. |
IN-PIPELINE (forward era, block 3 of run FWD-1). Zero web fetches. Manifest: logic/oral_audit/manifests/gen_62_potifar_house_claims.json — 11 VERIFIED · 0 FAILED · 1 UNCHECKABLE.
Sources: Minchat Shai on Gen 39 (seventeen notes) · Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 39 (eleven notes) (the Ramah; the Great Masorah — the counting tradition; the Meiri; the Hilleli codex; Rabbeinu Bachya; Rambam; Et Sofer).
CROWNS
- G62-01 Potiphar is one word: full yod, full vav — proven by omission from the Masorah's two-words-read-one list.
- G62-02 the prisoners written and read: אסורי ("the king's prisoners") written vav, read yod — FIRST of the Great Masorah's alphabet-list; SNAPSHOT carries the token-pair; the Kitzur's ten-plus-two years inside it.
- G62-03 the corrected word: האסירם unique — the printer's written/read error undone by the Ramah, Meiri, and Hilleli; the stream writes their form.
- G62-04 the refusal on the chain: וימאן ("and he refused") under the shalshelet (the chain-accent) — one of the Torah's four; Bachya's accents-as-meaning principle stated here.
- G62-05 his tongue in the finals: the handover clause's five finals spell לשונו ("his tongue") — Gabriel's seventy languages.
- G62-06 the bound pair: אסורים ("bound") — both Torah stations are Joseph's prison (39:20, 40:5); the release-verse (Psalms) named.
- G62-07 the raised hand and the raised voice: הרימתי ("I raised") exactly twice — Abram's oath (14:22) and the false cry: one word, an oath and a lie.
- G62-08/09 the two descents: הורד — Joseph and the ornaments (Exod 33:5); הורדהו exactly twice — the descent and "bring him down to me" (44:21): Judah's measure-for-measure.
- G62-10 the pointing set: כהרימי with the compound half-vowel under the guttural (checked); the mock-word's chet in segol, the this-word's zayin dagesheed (asserted).
DISCREPANCIES / GAPS
- G62-11: את of "saw not ANY thing" (39:23) — MS rules maqqef (the joining stroke) without a stress-stroke; SNAPSHOT joins the maqqef but writes the meteg his books omit. Filed.
- G62-12: the paragraph question at 39:7 — Sephardic books no break; Rambam + Hilleli open; the Meiri an undecided gap. Paragraph layer uninstrumented; camps recorded.
- One claim dropped at probe: MS's note that אוכל ("he ate") is full-once — its scope ("in its language") could not be framed against the 14-token census; not framed rather than misframed.
READINGS FILED (named-only)
The accent-variance file (39:14 merkha-on-the-he; 39:18's book shuffles); the kaf-dagesh puzzle at 39:15 ("I know not why" — MS); the margin's chilluf at 39:19; the two tellings as a rehearsed lie; the anger's unnamed target; the Kitzur's letter-sums (the bread = his wife; to-be-with-her = into Gehenna); Joseph's beauty in his mother's phrase.
TIMING + PROCESS NOTES
In-pipeline scan; lean-record mode; zero fetches. The his-work noun's census (opened at gen_07) closes inside this span.