ORAL AUDIT — gen_24_nations_table
Live verifier run: 10 VERIFIED 0 FAILED 1 UNCHECKABLE — re-run:
python3 logic/solo_tools/verify_claims.py logic/oral_audit/manifests/gen_24_nations_table_claims.jsonClaims manifest (verified live at render time)
| status | id | source | claim · evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| VERIFIED | G24-01 | Minchat Shai on Gen 10:19 (Ramah's four-member qere list) | וצבים ("and Tzevoyim," the border-list) — WRITTEN doubly defective, no vav and one yod, READ וצבוים (the Ramah's rule for this token; the Yerushalmi's two-yod spelling recorded and rejected). SNAPSHOT: the bare written skeleton locked. Instrument note: here the written/read pair is SINGLE-token encoded (the read-form living in the pronunciation layer), where 8:17's pair was dual-token — the encoding varies by site. letters=וצבימ vs וצבימ |
| VERIFIED | G24-02 | Minchat Shai on Gen 10:2 (Ramah — the Tubal rule's own anchor) | ותבל ("and Tubal," Japheth's son) — defective in all books (the Yerushalmi's ותובל rejected): the same Ramah note gen_13 verified from the other side — plene תובל belongs to Tubal-Cain's two tokens alone; Japheth's son goes bare. The rule now locked at BOTH its anchors. letters=ותבל vs ותבל |
| VERIFIED | G24-03 | Minchat Shai on Gen 10:9 (Masorah) | כנמרד גבור ציד ("like Nimrod, a MIGHTY hunter" — the proverb) — "this one alone plene with vav in the Torah in this phrasing; the first of this verse and all the rest defective": SNAPSHOT agrees to the letter — the narrative's mighty-words (10:8, and the verse's own first) bare, the PROVERB'S plene: the saying carries the full spelling. letters=גבור vs גבור |
| VERIFIED | G24-04 | Minchat Shai on Gen 10:9 | כנמרד ("like Nimrod") — "without maqqef" (the joining hyphen): the name stands free in the proverb. SNAPSHOT's maqqef column agrees. maqqef_after=0 |
| VERIFIED | G24-05 | Minchat Shai on Gen 10:11 (Masorah: none-defective) | רחבת עיר ("Rehovot-City," Asshur's build-list) — doubly defective in the precise majority, "and the Masorah on it: unique-defective." SNAPSHOT letter-exact. letters=רחבת vs רחבת |
| VERIFIED | G24-06 | Minchat Shai on Gen 10:31 (all books + Ramah vs Hilleli; Onkelos vs Yonatan) | לגויהם ("BY their nations," Shem's closing formula) — with LAMED in all our books and the Ramah; the Hilleli reads בגויהם with bet — and the TRANSLATIONS split as witnesses: Onkelos rendered like the bet, Yonatan ben Uzziel precisely like the lamed. SNAPSHOT: lamed — and the neighboring verse's בגויהם (10:32, bet) locked beside it by the Ramah's complementary rule. letters=לגויהמ vs לגויהמ |
| VERIFIED | G24-07 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 10:9 (Masorah) | על כן יאמר ("therefore it is SAID") — the Kitzur's trio: Nimrod's proverb (10:9), "therefore it is said in the Book of the Wars of the LORD" (Num 21:14), and "of Zion it shall be said" (Ps 87:5) — the war-hero, the war-book, and the city where every native is mighty. Torah-side: the passive said-word's only two tokens; the Psalms leg is an inheritance edge. count=2 refs=['Gen 10:9', 'Num 21:14'] |
| VERIFIED | G24-08 | Minchat Shai on Gen 10:26 (Ramah) | חצרמות ("Hazarmavet") — the Ramah: ONE WORD, the resh with sheva (Chronicles' parallel list spells its own way — see the edge layer). SNAPSHOT: a single token, letters locked. letters=חצרמות vs חצרמות |
| VERIFIED | G24-09 | Minchat Shai on Gen 10:28 | עובל ("Obal") — plene with vav HERE; "and in Chronicles with a yod" (עיבל, I Chr 1:22): the same man spelled differently across the two lists — a cross-book variant the tradition itself indexes. SNAPSHOT: the Torah spelling locked. letters=עובל vs עובל |
| VERIFIED | G24-10 | Minchat Shai on Gen 10:32 | נפרדו הגוים ("the nations DIVIDED") — the gimel with dagesh (doubling dot). SNAPSHOT agrees. he=יִ֛ם |
| UNCHECKABLE | G24-11 | Minchat Shai on Gen 10:6 (Or Torah) | "The printer ERRED making a paragraph break here" (before Ham's line) — though the Hilleli HAS a section here, "all Torah scrolls of Jerusalem and Ashkenaz have none, and neither Rambam nor Meiri" count one: a PARAGRAPH DISPUTE between the codices themselves. SNAPSHOT carries no paragraph instrumentation — gap class of G12-11, now with a documented two-camp case. petucha/setuma uninstrumented; this site is a genuine inter-codex paragraph dispute (Hilleli yes; Jerusalem/Ashkenaz scrolls, Rambam, Meiri no) |
FOLDED INTO THE UNIT same day (one source of truth). Block 3 of the third five-block run. Zero web fetches. Manifest: logic/oral_audit/manifests/gen_24_nations_table_claims.json — 10 VERIFIED · 0 FAILED · 1 UNCHECKABLE, zero-iteration pass. The edge-richest span yet: SIX attested edges plus one claim-borne — the nations table is the canon's address book, and the link index knows.
Sources: Minchat Shai on Gen 10 (23 notes — name-spelling dense) · Kitzur Baal HaTurim 10:9 · span map (Bereshit Rabbah 37).
CROWNS (chain-attested + DB-verified)
- G24-03 the proverb's full spelling: כנמרד גבור ציד ("like Nimrod, a MIGHTY hunter") — the Masorah: this גבור alone plene in the Torah in this phrasing; the narrative's mighty-words (10:8 and the verse's own first) stay bare. SNAPSHOT letter-exact: the SAYING carries the full spelling the story withholds.
- G24-07 therefore it is said: יאמר (the passive said-word) — exactly two Torah tokens: Nimrod's proverb (10:9) and the Book of the Wars of the LORD (Num 21:14); the Kitzur's trio adds Zion's every-native-mighty verse (Ps 87:5) — war-hero, war-book, and the city of the mighty.
- G24-01 the written Tzevoyim: וצבים — written doubly defective, read וצבוים (the Ramah's four-member written/read list for this name). Instrument note: single-token encoding here vs 8:17's dual-token — the written/read layer's encoding varies by site.
- G24-02 the Tubal rule closes: ותבל (Japheth's son) defective — the same Ramah note gen_13 verified from Tubal-Cain's side, now locked at BOTH anchors.
- G24-06 lamed against bet, translations as witnesses: לגויהם ("BY their nations," 10:31) — all books and the Ramah lamed, the Hilleli bet — and the split runs through the TRANSLATIONS: Onkelos rendered like the bet, Yonatan ben Uzziel precisely the lamed. SNAPSHOT: lamed, with 10:32's true bet locked beside it.
- G24-05/08/09 name-spellings: רחבת ("Rehovot-City") unique- defective; חצרמות one word per the Ramah; עובל plene here where Chronicles writes yod — the cross-book variant the tradition itself indexes.
- G24-04/10 the free-standing כנמרד (no maqqef); the dotted gimel of the dividing (10:32).
DISCREPANCIES
None (the paragraph dispute at 10:6 is inter-codex, filed as gap).
INHERITANCE EDGES (attested in export_links; Torah side verified)
- Gen 10:1-30 → I Chronicles 1:5 and 10:4 → I Chr 1:7 — the Chronicles mirror-list: the whole table inherited as the opening of Israel's own genealogy. THE structural edge of the span.
- Gen 10:12 → Jonah 1:2 — Nineveh "the GREAT city" built here, inherited by Jonah's commission to it.
- Gen 10:14 → Amos 9:7 and → Jeremiah 47:4 — the Caphtorim, inherited by "the Philistines from Caphtor."
- Gen 10:18 → Ezekiel 27:8 — the Arvadite, inherited into Tyre's lament-roster.
- G24-07's Psalms leg (87:5) rides as a verified claim.
INSTRUMENT GAPS
- G24-11 the 10:6 paragraph DISPUTE — the Hilleli has a break, the Jerusalem and Ashkenaz scrolls (with Rambam and Meiri) have none, and the printer's break is "an error" (Or Torah): the paragraph gap class (G12-11), now holding a genuine two-camp case the instrument cannot see.
READINGS FILED (named-only, unclaimed)
Nimrod the city-taker reading on the trio (Kitzur 10:9) · the Sephardic tsere/patach splits on וכלנה and הערקי and the softness notes on גררה / ורעמה (Minchat Shai — pronunciation class, no letter at stake, named-only).
TIMING + PROCESS NOTES
BLOCK CYCLE — 3 minutes 12 seconds (14:05:47-14:08:59). Zero-iteration pass — the scripted-codepoint discipline held (only simple two-char patterns hand-typed). The 32-verse name-table cost one probe batch: name-lists are CHEAP to audit because every claim is letters_multiset. Edge harvest: the table is the canon's address book — six attested edges, the most of any span, exactly as the design session predicted for genealogy/geography blocks.