ORAL AUDIT — gen_21_blessing_blood_law
python3 logic/solo_tools/verify_claims.py logic/oral_audit/manifests/gen_21_blessing_blood_law_claims.jsonClaims manifest (verified live at render time)
| status | id | source | claim · evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| VERIFIED | G21-01 | Minchat Shai on Gen 9:2 | כל חית הארץ ("every beast of the earth," the dread-clause) — the yod carries a dagesh (doubling dot). SNAPSHOT agrees. he=ַּ֣ת |
| VERIFIED | G21-02 | Minchat Shai on Gen 9:2 | דגי הים ("the fish of the sea") — the yod of the sea-word with dagesh (doubling dot). SNAPSHOT agrees. he=ָּ֖ם |
| VERIFIED | G21-03 | Minchat Shai on Gen 9:2 (Ben Asher; the precise books) | ובכל ("and in every [fish of the sea]") — the vav carries the lengthening mark (maarikh, the small vertical stroke) "per Ben Asher, and so in the precise books." SNAPSHOT's codepoints: vav, its vowel-dot, and the stroke — the Ben Asher reading locked. he=/כָל |
| VERIFIED | G21-04 | Minchat Shai on Gen 9:4 | בשר בנפשו דמו ("flesh with its life, its BLOOD") — the first blood-word's dalet is SOFT (no dagesh): dalet+vowel contiguous in SNAPSHOT. he=֖/וֹ |
| VERIFIED | G21-05 | Minchat Shai on Gen 9:7 (Great Masorah) | שרצו בארץ ("SWARM in the earth," the renewed blessing) — the Great Masorah lists it among the pairs that take NO vav at the word's head, "and the copies err in them": here bare, unlike the true ושרצו ("and they shall swarm") of the exit-command (8:17) — both forms locked one chapter apart. letters=שרצו vs שרצו |
| VERIFIED | G21-06 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 9:5 (Masorah) | ואך ("and yet") — the Kitzur's Masorah trio: the blood-reckoning (9:5), Balaam's "yet ONLY the word I speak" (Num 22:20), and "yet if the land of your possession is unclean" (Josh 22:19): as one may not kill oneself, one may not curse oneself — even SPEECH is reckoned. Torah-side: exactly the two tokens of this pointing (Pharaoh's ואך, Exod 9:15, is another vocalization); the Joshua leg is an inheritance edge. count=2 refs=['Gen 9:5', 'Num 22:20'] |
FOLDED INTO THE UNIT same day (one source of truth). Block 5 of the second five-block run. Zero web fetches. Manifest: logic/oral_audit/manifests/gen_21_blessing_blood_law_claims.json — 6 VERIFIED · 0 FAILED · 0 UNCHECKABLE, zero-iteration pass. The Gen 9 chapter query banked a heavy load for the NEXT blocks: the covenant-spelling cluster (9:11/12/17 — including R. Yudan's missing-generations teaching on the doubly-defective לדרת), and the 9:29 ויהי/ויהיו dispute — Minchat Shai's longest note in Genesis so far, a full manuscript-and-Masorah war over Noah's death-total verb.
Sources: Minchat Shai on Gen 9 (20 notes; 9:8-29 banked) · Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 9 (5 notes; 9:20-25 banked) · span map (Bereshit Rabbah 34; Sanhedrin 56-59 — the Noahide-law loci).
CROWNS (chain-attested + DB-verified)
- G21-03 Ben Asher's stroke: ובכל ("and in every [fish of the sea]") — the vav carries the lengthening mark (maarikh) "per Ben Asher, and so in the precise books": SNAPSHOT's codepoints hold vav, vowel-dot, AND the stroke — a Ben Asher reading confirmed at the sub-vowel level (the second BA confirmation of the program, after gen_11's chataf patach — the hurried a-vowel).
- G21-05 the vav the copyists add: שרצו ("SWARM," the renewed blessing, 9:7) — the Great Masorah lists it among the word-pairs that take NO vav at the head, "and the copies err in them": SNAPSHOT holds it bare, one chapter after the true ושרצו of the exit-command (8:17) — both forms locked, the erring-copyist trap documented by the tradition itself.
- G21-06 the self-curse trio: ואך ("and yet") — the blood-reckoning (9:5), Balaam's speech-limit (Num 22:20), and Joshua's unclean-land clause (22:19): one may not kill oneself, one may not curse oneself — even speech is reckoned (Kitzur). Torah-side: exactly the two tokens of this pointing.
- G21-01/02/04 pointing confirmations: yod dagesh in the beast-word and the sea-word (9:2); the first blood-word's dalet soft (9:4).
DISCREPANCIES
None in span.
INHERITANCE EDGES (attested; Torah side verified)
- Gen 9:4-6 → Isaiah 24:5 — the blood-law block linked to "they transgressed the teachings... broke the EVERLASTING COVENANT": the prophets reading the Noahide charge back at the world. Edge attested; inheritor wording pending.
- G21-06's Joshua leg (22:19) rides as a verified claim.
READINGS FILED (named-only, unclaimed)
כי בצלם אלהים ("for in the image of God," 9:6) — the Name ruled HOLY (Minchat Shai: קדש, "holy") — the third entry in the holy/profane classification series (5:1 holy, 6:2 profane, 9:6 holy), still uninstrumented · the Noahide loci named by the span map (Sanhedrin 56-59) — the unit's law-side dossier, named-only.
TIMING + PROCESS NOTES
BLOCK CYCLE — 2 minutes 40 seconds (13:52:17-13:54:57). Zero-iteration pass. The bank for gen_22+ out of this one chapter query is the largest yet — the covenant-spelling cluster and the 9:29 verb-war are pre-read, which should make the rainbow block fast. Ben Asher confirmations now have a small series (chataf patach, maarikh) — the sub-vowel layer of SNAPSHOT consistently matches his school where Minchat Shai reports a split.