ORAL AUDIT — gen_11_sentences_exile
python3 logic/solo_tools/verify_claims.py logic/oral_audit/manifests/gen_11_sentences_exile_claims.jsonClaims manifest (verified live at render time)
| status | id | source | claim · evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| VERIFIED | G11-01 | Minchat Shai on Gen 3:19 (Masorah) | אפיך ("your nostrils") is written FULL with a yod exactly twice: בזעת אפיך ("in the sweat of your nostrils," Gen 3:19) and ברוח אפיך ("by the breath of Your nostrils" the waters piled up, Exod 15:8) — the Masorah's own mnemonic: man's livelihood is as hard as the splitting of the Sea of Reeds. full=['Exod 15:8', 'Gen 3:19'] of 4 tokens |
| VERIFIED | G11-02 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 3:21 | וילבשם ("and He clothed them") appears twice in the Masorah (the received spelling tradition): here and Lev 8:13 (Moses clothes Aaron's sons in tunics) — teaching that the Holy One made PRIESTLY garments for the first man; Bereshit Rabbah adds the firstborn served in them. count=2 refs=['Gen 3:21', 'Lev 8:13'] |
| VERIFIED | G11-03 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 3:21 | The garments verse has exactly EIGHT words — corresponding to the eight garments of the priesthood. words=8 |
| VERIFIED | G11-04 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 3:15 (Masorah) | עקב ("heel") in this pointing stands three times in the Masorah's list: the serpent's heel-strike (3:15), Gad's blessing והוא יגד עקב ("he shall raid at the heel," Gen 49:19 — the Kitzur folds the serpent-likened tribes into one blessing), and Ps 41:10 (outside the Torah DB). Torah-side: exactly the two. count=2 refs=['Gen 3:15', 'Gen 49:19'] |
| VERIFIED | G11-05 | Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 3:24 | לשמר ("to guard") read as a notarikon (initial-letter cipher): its four letters open לילין שדין מזיקין רוחין ("night-beings, demons, harmers, spirits") — the guarded way warded against them. SNAPSHOT locks the cipher's base letters. letters=לשמר vs לשמר |
| VERIFIED | G11-06 | Minchat Shai on Gen 3:14 | זאת ("this") in the serpent's indictment carries a dagesh (doubling dot) in the zayin — the doubling that binds it to עשית ("you did") before it. he=ֹאת֒ |
| VERIFIED | G11-07 | Minchat Shai on Gen 3:16 | עצבונך ("your toil") — the tsadi carries a dagesh (doubling dot). he=֣/ךְ |
| VERIFIED | G11-08 | Minchat Shai on Gen 3:19 (Masorah Gedolah) | כי עפר אתה ("for dust you are") — אתה ("you") carries zaqef qatan ("small upright," a pause accent) and is stressed on its FIRST syllable; the Great Masorah's list of first-syllable-stressed אתה opens HERE: the mortality verse heads the list. mark=zaqef_qatan |
| VERIFIED | G11-09 | Minchat Shai on Gen 3:18 | ודרדר ("and thistles") — both dalets pointed with patach (the flat a-vowel); some copies point the second with qamatz, and Minchat Shai rules patach with all his books — SNAPSHOT sides with the ruling. he=ַּ֖ר |
| VERIFIED | G11-10 | Minchat Shai on Gen 3:19 | בזעת ("in the sweat") — the precise codices read mahpach ("inverted horn" accent) on the ayin; SNAPSHOT's chain reads exactly that. mark=mahpach |
| VERIFIED | G11-11 | Minchat Shai on Gen 3:17 | כי שמעת ("because you listened") — "must be with ONE zarqa only, on the tav": the zarqa (= zinor, "pipe" accent) the unit's own parse flagged as the rare near-poetic register marker over both sentence-openers, attested from outside. mark=zinor |
| VERIFIED | G11-12 | Minchat Shai on Gen 3:14 | ויאמר ("and He said") opening the serpent's sentence carries telisha qetana ("small detached" accent; Minchat Shai's term tarsa) — "one sign only, on the resh": the postpositive sign sits once, on the word's last letter. mark=telisha_qetana |
| VERIFIED | G11-13 | Minchat Shai on Gen 3:21 | ויעש ("and He made") of the garments verse likewise carries telisha qetana ("small detached" accent) — "one tarsa alone." mark=telisha_qetana |
| VERIFIED | G11-14 | Minchat Shai on Gen 3:17 (Ben Asher vs Ben Naftali) | תאכלנה ("you shall eat of it") — Ben Naftali reads the kaf with plain sheva; Ben Asher, "on whom we rely," with chataf patach (the hurried a-vowel) — SNAPSHOT reads chataf patach: the letter follows Ben Asher. he=נָּה |
| VERIFIED | G11-15 | Bereshit Rabbah 20:12 | "In the Torah of Rabbi Meir they found written כתנות אור — garments of LIGHT" (aleph for ayin): the tradition's own record of a manuscript variant. The received letter and SNAPSHOT read עור ("skin") with ayin — the frozen unit's letter-variant detector tripwire, now read at its source. letters=עור vs עור |
| UNCHECKABLE | G11-16 | Minchat Shai on Gen 3:14 | Minchat Shai reads galgal ("wheel," the day-old-moon accent) on אלהים ("God") and on כי ("because" — "with galgal, not maqqef," the joining hyphen) where SNAPSHOT's chain reads mercha / munach (both conjunctive accents) — manuscript accent-variant class, same class as gen_10's revia gap. accent variant vs SNAPSHOT chain; galgal absent from SNAPSHOT's mark inventory at these tokens — manuscript-class, uncheckable |
FOLDED INTO THE UNIT same day (standing order: one source of truth). FIRST audit under the Hebrew-script display convention — Hebrew letters + English gloss only, transliteration retired; fold linted with gloss_lint.py --no-translit. Zero web fetches (local mirror). Manifest: logic/oral_audit/manifests/gen_11_sentences_exile_claims.json — 15 VERIFIED · 0 FAILED · 1 UNCHECKABLE.
Sources read locally: Kitzur Baal HaTurim on Gen 3:14-24 (6 notes) · Minchat Shai on Gen 3:14-24 (11 notes) · Rashi on Gen 3:14-24 (23 notes) · Bereshit Rabbah 20:12 raw · citation span map (Bereshit Rabbah ×54, Midrash Lekach Tov ("Good Lesson," the anthology commentary) ×47, Yalkut Shimoni ×42, Chizkuni, Radak, Ibn Ezra).
CROWNS (chain-attested + DB-verified)
- G11-01 the sweat and the sea: אפיך ("your nostrils") is written FULL with its yod exactly twice — the sweat-bread sentence (3:19) and "by the breath of Your nostrils the waters piled up" (Exod 15:8). The Masorah's (the received text tradition's) own mnemonic: man's livelihood is as hard as the splitting of the Sea of Reeds. Check discriminates 2 of 4 tokens (the defective "your anger" tokens, Exod 32:12 / Deut 33:10, stay outside).
- G11-02/03 the priestly garments: וילבשם ("and He clothed them") appears twice per the Masorah — Adam here (3:21), Aaron's sons at Lev 8:13 — the tradition's teaching that God made the first man PRIESTLY garments; and the verse runs exactly EIGHT words, against the eight garments of the priesthood (Kitzur). The frozen unit's own skin-word import chain to lev_13 now carries the tradition's priestly arrow beside it. (The Kitzur's English translation says "eight LETTERS" — the Hebrew says תיבות, "words": paraphrase-loss caught by reading the raw source.)
- G11-04 the two heels: עקב ("heel") in this pointing has exactly two Torah tokens — the serpent's strike-target (3:15) and Gad's blessing "he shall raid at the heel" (49:19); the Kitzur's Masorah-trio adds Ps 41:10 (outside the Torah DB) and folds the serpent-likened tribes into one blessing.
- G11-05 the warding cipher: לשמר ("to guard," 3:24) read as notarikon (initial-letter cipher): לילין שדין מזיקין רוחין ("night-beings, demons, harmers, spirits") — the guard-word's own letters ward the way.
- G11-06/07 dagesh (doubling dot) notes verified at the letter: the zayin of זאת ("this," 3:14), the tsadi of עצבונך ("your toil," 3:16).
- G11-08 the mortality verse heads the list: אתה ("you") in כי עפר אתה ("for dust you are," 3:19) carries zaqef qatan ("small upright," a pause accent) and opens the Great Masorah's list of first-syllable-stressed אתה.
- G11-14 the letter follows Ben Asher: תאכלנה ("you shall eat of it," 3:17) — Ben Naftali reads plain sheva (the bare half-vowel) in the kaf; Ben Asher, "on whom we rely" (Minchat Shai), chataf patach (the hurried a-vowel). SNAPSHOT's codepoints: chataf patach.
- G11-15 the detector tripwire closed: Bereshit Rabbah 20:12 read raw — "in the Torah of Rabbi Meir they found written כתנות אור, garments of LIGHT" (aleph for ayin). The frozen note flagged this as the letter-variant detector test; it is the tradition's own record of a manuscript variant, and the received letter עור ("skin," ayin) is SNAPSHOT-confirmed.
ATTESTING the frozen unit — Minchat Shai's accent rulings land on SNAPSHOT's own marks: the zarqa (= zinor, "pipe" accent) he demands on שמעת ("you listened," 3:17) is the unit's derived near-poetic register marker (G11-11); telisha qetana ("small detached" accent, his tarsa) on both ויאמר ("and He said," 3:14) and ויעש ("and He made," 3:21) (G11-12/13); mahpach ("inverted horn") on בזעת ("in the sweat," 3:19) per the precise codices (G11-10); ודרדר ("and thistles," 3:18) both dalets patach per his ruling against the qamatz copies (G11-09). Rashi 3:14 answers the unit's [OPEN] never-questioned-serpent flag from the chain (no defense is offered an inciter — Sanhedrin 29a); Rashi 3:15 names the שוף ("bruise") pair a deliberate wordplay — the unit's only-two-tokens census; Rashi 3:18 grounds the herb-of-the-field diet downgrade in Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer 14; Rashi 3:24 keeps the expulsion geometry ("east OF the garden — outside it").
READINGS FILED (named-only, unclaimed)
Eve named for speech — שמחוה ("for she expresses"), with the "ten measures of speech" saying (Kitzur 3:20; Rashi derives from חיה, "life," with the yod/vav interchange) · the woman's עצבון ("toil") as the monthly blood (Kitzur 3:16) · thorns-and-thistles as the nations (Kitzur 3:18) · the serpent's seven-year gestation (Bekhorot 8a via Rashi 3:14) · the serpent's feet cut off (Bereshit Rabbah 20:5) · the cherubim as angels of destruction (Exodus Rabbah 9:11 via Rashi 3:24) · "like one of us" = unique among the terrestrial as He is among the celestial (Bereshit Rabbah 21:5 via Rashi 3:22 — standing beside the unit's Onkelos "unique in the world" Tier-A witness) · garments smooth as fingernail, lovely as pearls (Bereshit Rabbah 20:12).
DISCREPANCIES
None.
INSTRUMENT GAPS
- G11-16 Minchat Shai's galgal ("wheel," the day-old-moon accent) on אלהים ("God") and on כי ("because" — "with galgal, not maqqef," the joining hyphen) at 3:14, where SNAPSHOT's chain reads mercha / munach (conjunctive accents) — manuscript accent-variant class, same class as gen_10's revia gap.
TIMING + PROCESS NOTES
FULL CYCLE — scan to rendered pages — 17 minutes 47 seconds (12:36:23-12:54:10), including one mid-run session interrupt + resume and two glossing-lint fix rounds; the dense Minchat Shai span (11 notes, all letter-class) made this the largest manifest of the program (16 rows vs gen_10's 11). One verifier iteration: G11-09's pattern typed with the vowel before the dagesh — the gen_10 codepoint-order lesson again (SNAPSHOT writes consonant, dagesh, vowel; the fix was scripted with explicit codepoints, not retyped). NEW verifier check type verse_word_count (verse's word total — the Kitzur's eight-words claim had no check; ~5 lines). Paraphrase-loss catch #3: Kitzur's English said "eight letters," Hebrew says eight WORDS — raw-Hebrew reading is the only safe layer. Minchat Shai's Sephardic accent names decoded against SNAPSHOT's inventory: tarsa = telisha qetana ("small detached"), zarqa = zinor ("pipe"), shofar hafukh = mahpach ("inverted horn"), galgal = the day-old-moon mark (absent here — the gap above).